Amalgamation, or shared services, is the debate that no one is having, because it is in no one’s interest except that of the ratepayers and citizens. And their voice – which should be represented by the press, if no one else – is stifled, because the media relies very heavily on government and local body advertising for their revenues. No one, least of all the press barons, are sharpening up the cutlery set to dismember the golden goose.
At a national level, there is a similar process, but it concerns the quality of government spending. In my time as a local body representative, I have seen first hand the wastage, inefficiency and duplication that has cost us millions and millions of dollars. But any call to reduce government expenditure is greeted with howls of protest. There are few calls to make expenditure more effective.
But how many other rorts and rip-offs and straight thefts lie undiscovered? How much skimming and scamming is going on in all the other DHBs and government agencies around this fair land of Aotoeroa. We don’t know. The Office of the Auditor-General checks processes and policies and makes sure the numbered vouchers are in order. They don’t really go looking for dishonest practices. There is a fine line between proper and necessary spending and a pet project pushed by an interest group with mates who stand to benefit. But that debate is never heard in public.
I am convinced, after fourteen years at district council and regional council level that Hawke’s Bay would be better off by millions of dollars a year and would be run much more efficiently as a single entity. The one proviso is that we would need a functioning independent press to scrutinise the larger body to stop it becoming a bigger monster than its component parts. And we would need an audit department that does more than pull out files and make sure they conform to government policy guidelines.
The issue is proven by the councils’ collective budgets for the investigation into shared services and the timelines built into annual plans. They are miniscule or non-existent. I think we plan to send $25,000 in three years time to think about amalgamation. In this case, words speak louder than action.